OpenAI o1 preview Doctor beating others!
OpenAI o1 preview Doctor beating others!
So essentially,
o1 preview is the best AI doctor so far
Paper: A Preliminary Study of o1 in Medicine: Are We Closer to an AI Doctor? (23 Pages)
Website: https://ucsc-vlaa.github.io/o1_medicine/
Researchers from UC Santa Cruz, University of Edinburgh and National Institute of Healthcare are interested in determining if o1's enhanced abilities in general language tasks translate to the specialized field of medicine and if we are moving closer to an "AI Doctor".
Hmm..What’s the background?
The researchers evaluate o1's performance in understanding, reasoning, and multilingual capabilities across 37 medical datasets, including two newly constructed question-answering (QA) tasks based on medical quizzes from the New England Journal of Medicine and The Lancet. These new datasets are considered more clinically relevant compared to existing benchmarks.
The study also investigates the impact of different prompting strategies, such as direct prompting, chain-of-thought, and few-shot prompting, on o1's performance. The study compares o1's performance to other LLMs like GPT-3.5, GPT-4, MEDITRON-70B, and Llama3-8B.
Ok, So what is proposed in the research paper?
The evaluation centers around three fundamental aspects crucial for an AI system operating in the medical field:
Understanding: This aspect focuses on o1’s ability to comprehend medical concepts and extract relevant information from medical texts.
Reasoning: This aspect assesses o1's ability to apply logical thinking and medical knowledge to solve complex clinical problems.
Multilinguality: This aspect examines o1's ability to understand and generate responses in languages other than English, reflecting the global nature of healthcare.
The evaluation employs a total of 37 medical datasets encompassing six core tasks. These datasets include both existing benchmarks and two novel datasets (LancetQA and NEJMQA) created by the researchers, designed to assess o1's performance on real-world medical challenges.
As results, o1 excels in clinical knowledge understanding and reasoning in diagnostic scenarios. For example, o1 shows significant improvements over GPT-4 and GPT-3.5 in accurately answering complex medical questions from NEJMQA and LancetQA datasets. It also demonstrates strong performance in medical calculation tasks, surpassing GPT-4 on the MedCalc-Bench.
o1 demonstrates superior performance compared to other LLMs (GPT-3.5, GPT-4, MEDITRON-70B, and Llama3-8B) in most medical tasks, particularly in understanding and reasoning. This suggests that o1's enhanced internal reasoning abilities, developed using chain-of-thought techniques and reinforcement learning, translate well to the medical domain.
What’s next?
The sources emphasize that realizing the full potential of LLMs like o1 in medicine requires continuous research and development in model training, prompting techniques, evaluation methods, and ethical considerations. Addressing these challenges will be crucial for building trustworthy and effective AI systems that can assist healthcare professionals and improve patient care.
So essentially,
o1 preview is the best AI doctor so far
Learned something new? Consider sharing with your friends!